Health insurance vs a health plan: the differences that matter
A health plan is a discount card; health insurance pays costs up to a sum insured. See the differences, according to the ASF and the ERS, and when each one makes sense.
| Health insurance (seguro de saúde) | Health plan or card (plano or cartão de saúde) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | An insurance contract: the insurer takes on part of the risk of the costs | A discount card for a network of providers |
| Who pays the cost | The insurer pays the covered part; the user pays co-payments and excesses | The user always pays, at a discount |
| Who sells it | An insurer authorised by the ASF, directly or through a broker | Healthcare providers, banks, insurers or other organisations |
| Supervision | ASF (Autoridade de Supervisão de Seguros e Fundos de Pensões, the Portuguese insurance supervisor) | Not supervised by the ASF; the ERS acts in relation to providers |
| Sums insured and limits | An annual sum insured per cover (for example, hospital and outpatient) | No sum insured: there is a price or discount list |
| Waiting periods | Yes, per cover | As a rule, no |
| Exclusions and pre-existing conditions | Yes, depending on the contract | As a rule, it does not exclude them, because it does not pay costs |
| Health questionnaire | Usually required | Usually not |
| Reimbursement outside the network | May exist, depending on the contract | No |
| Protection for surgery or a hospital stay | Pays up to the hospital sum insured | Only the agreed discount |
“That is a health plan, not health insurance.” The phrase comes up again and again on Portuguese personal finance forums, almost always in reply to someone who took out a cheap product thinking they were insured. The confusion is understandable: both come with a card, a network of doctors and a monthly fee. But they work in opposite ways, and the difference only shows when a big bill arrives.
What health insurance is
Health insurance (seguro de saúde) is an insurance contract. In exchange for a premium, an insurer authorised by the Autoridade de Supervisão de Seguros e Fundos de Pensões (ASF, the Portuguese insurance supervisor) takes on part of the risk of your health costs, under the terms and up to the limits of the contract.
According to the Entidade Reguladora da Saúde (ERS, the health regulator), access to care under an insurance policy can work in three ways:
- Network (rede convencionada). You go to a provider in the network, pay a share (the co-payment) and the insurer pays the rest directly to the provider.
- Reimbursement. You choose any provider, pay the bill and the insurer later reimburses part of it.
- Mixed system. You can use both.
Insurance has rules that a plan does not, precisely because it pays costs. It has sums insured, meaning an annual maximum per cover. It has waiting periods, during which some covers do not yet apply. It has exclusions, usually including pre-existing conditions. And it usually requires a health questionnaire before accepting you.
To give a concrete idea, in the 2025 documents of the two largest health insurers, a consultation in the network costs €19 and a hospital stay costs the insured person 10% of the bill, with a minimum of €250 and a maximum of €500. The insurer pays the rest, up to the sum insured: €50,000 of hospital cover on the mid-range plans from Médis and Multicare. See the full comparison in Médis vs Multicare.
What a health plan is
A health plan, also called a health card (plano de saúde or cartão de saúde), gives access to a network of providers at agreed prices. The ASF is clear: a health plan is not an insurance contract but a discount card. So it is not subject to the same legal rules as insurance, or to ASF supervision.
The ERS explains that the organisation issuing the card is usually a healthcare provider, another organisation with social aims, a bank or an insurer. The member uses the network's services and pays only part of the price, but that part is always paid by them: nobody takes on the cost in their place.
This leads to the plan's advantages and limits:
- No waiting period and no health questionnaire, because there is no risk to assess.
- No exclusion of pre-existing conditions, for the same reason.
- No sum insured. For example, for a hypothetical €8,000 operation, you pay €8,000 minus the agreed discount. With insurance with a high enough sum insured, you would pay the co-payment.
- Only valid in the card's network. Outside it, there is no reimbursement.
The differences in brief
The table at the top of this page sums up the differences. In practice, the deciding question is: what happens on the day you need surgery or a hospital stay? With insurance, the bill is limited to the co-payment and anything above the sum insured. With a plan, the bill is yours, at a discount.
One comment on a personal finance forum put it this way, in other words: if what you want is discounts on consultations, a plan may do; if you need surgery and tests, you need insurance. It is a useful rule, as long as you remember that you do not know today what you will need tomorrow.
The ASF standard health insurance
To make insurance easier to compare, the ASF published Circular n.º 6/2025 of 3 June 2025, with the “standard conditions” for health insurance. It is a reference, not an obligation: insurers may or may not offer it, and each one sets its own price.
According to the Lusa news agency report published in DN, the standard policy includes:
- Hospital cover with a sum insured of €30,000;
- Outpatient cover with a sum insured of €1,000, with co-payments of €10 for scheduled consultations, €45 for urgent ones, €10 for tests, €30 for CT scans and €70 for MRI scans;
- Extended-cover illnesses with a sum insured of €300,000;
- Preventive medicine.
It does not include dental care, prostheses, orthoses or medicines. At least one insurer already sells a product it says meets these conditions: Multicare Proteção Padrão, with pre-contractual information dated December 2025. The ASF had announced that in early 2026 it would publish the list of insurers offering this product; check the current list on the ASF website.
The standard policy is useful even if you do not take it out, because it gives a baseline: a policy with less than €30,000 of hospital cover is below the regulator's benchmark.
When a health plan can make sense
- You want discounts on routine consultations, tests or dental care, and accept paying the rest.
- You have a condition that insurers exclude and want at least lower prices in the private network.
- You already have hospital-only insurance and want to complement the consultations side.
- You have a card included with another service (bank, telecoms, supermarket) and want to use it, knowing what it is.
Before joining, check whether the network has doctors near you and whether the card has a minimum commitment period. These two points come up often in complaints and in advice shared on forums.
When you need health insurance
- You want protection against large costs: surgery, hospital stays, cancer treatment.
- You want to choose where and when you have surgery, without depending on the waiting list.
- You are thinking of having children and want to give birth in the private sector (policies usually have a 365-day waiting period for childbirth, so plan for that).
- You have only recently moved to Portugal and do not yet have full access to the SNS (Serviço Nacional de Saúde, the national health service).
If your budget is tight, hospital-only insurance usually costs much less than a policy with outpatient cover. In the health insurance guide you will find examples of premiums by age.
Signs you are buying a plan and not insurance
- The document does not mention “sum insured” (capital seguro), “policy” (apólice) or “policyholder” (tomador do seguro).
- You are not asked to fill in a health questionnaire.
- The price is very low for your age (a few euros a month).
- The document only mentions “discounts” or “agreed prices” (preços convencionados).
- The organisation selling it is not an insurer registered with the ASF. You can check the registration on the ASF website.
Note that some insurers call the options of their insurance policies “plans”. DECO Proteste (the consumer association) reported that the ASF recommended insurers avoid the term “plano” (plan) so as not to cause confusion. If in doubt, look for the word “seguro” (insurance) and the reference to ASF registration in the pre-contractual information.
Talk to us before you decide
Dourado's is an insurance broker (an intermediary registered with the ASF). We can explain whether the product you have is insurance or a discount card, and request health insurance quotes from several insurers to compare with what you already have. Request a quote.
General information. It does not replace the pre-contractual and contractual information for each product.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between health insurance and a health plan?
Health insurance is an insurance contract: the insurer pays part of the costs, up to the sums insured. A health plan is a discount card: it gives access to lower prices in a network, but the user always pays the bill. The ASF describes the health plan as a discount card, which is not subject to the rules of the insurance contract or to its supervision.
Does a health plan have a waiting period?
As a rule, no, because it does not pay costs: it only applies discounts. Health insurance has waiting periods per cover, for example 60 days for consultations and 90 to 180 days for hospital stays in the documents we consulted.
Does a health plan cover pre-existing conditions?
Because it does not pay costs, a health plan does not usually exclude pre-existing conditions and does not ask for a health questionnaire. With health insurance, it is usual for the contract to exclude known pre-existing conditions.
Can I have health insurance and a health plan at the same time?
Yes. Some people use a hospital-only policy for the big risks and a discount card for routine consultations. Check that the providers you use are in both networks.
What is the ASF standard health insurance?
It is a set of reference conditions the ASF defined in Circular n.º 6/2025 of 3 June 2025: €30,000 of hospital cover, €1,000 of outpatient cover and €300,000 for extended-cover illnesses. Insurers are not required to offer it and each one sets its own price.
Would you like help comparing your situation?
Tell us what you are looking for. We review the options with you, with no obligation.
Request a quote
