Dourado's, insurance consultants
    Blog

    The strangest things ever insured (and the ones that are pure myth)

    A £10 million tongue, the Loch Ness Monster and alien abduction cover: the world's strangest insurance policies, and which stories are true.

    A coffee taster's tongue, a winemaker's nose and a prize for whoever caught the Loch Ness Monster. All of these were genuinely insured, almost always at Lloyd's of London. Tom Jones's famous chest-hair policy, on the other hand, never existed, and the Mona Lisa was never actually insured.

    We went back to the sources to separate the documented cases from the stories that have done the rounds for years without proof. The amounts below are the ones reported at the time. They are maximum sums insured, not claims paid, and none of these contracts has ever been published in full.

    Body parts: the confirmed cases

    Gennaro Pelliccia's tongue. In March 2009, Costa Coffee insured its master taster's tongue for £10 million with Lloyd's. Pelliccia tastes the brand's coffee batches, so a damaged palate would have left him unable to work. Lloyd's did the maths itself: roughly £1,000 per taste bud. The company paid for the cover, not the taster.

    Ilja Gort's nose. In 2008 the Dutch winemaker, who owns a vineyard near Bordeaux, insured his sense of smell under a bespoke policy written by a Lloyd's syndicate together with Allianz Nederland. Insurance Journal reported a valuation of €5 million. Other sources say 8 million, so the exact figure remains unclear.

    America Ferrera's smile. In May 2007 the Ugly Betty star had her smile insured for up to $10 million, again at Lloyd's. It was part of an Aquafresh toothpaste campaign linked to a charity drive, and it was always presented as such.

    Heidi Klum's legs. The model confirmed in a 2017 interview that her legs were insured for around $2.2 million, with a different value for each leg. She made clear that a client had taken out the policy, not her.

    The Hollywood pioneers. Lloyd's own history page records cases going back almost a century. In the 1920s, silent-film comedian Ben Turpin insured his crossed eyes for $25,000, and the policy paid out if his eyes ever uncrossed, because they were his trademark. In the 1930s Jimmy Durante insured his nose for $140,000. The 1940s brought Betty Grable's legs, insured for $1 million according to Lloyd's (Guinness gives $1.25 million).

    The names that only appear on a list

    The same Lloyd's page lists other famous cases without dates or terms: Bruce Springsteen's voice (£3.5 million), Keith Richards's hands ($1.6 million), David Beckham's legs (£100 million, in 2006) and the moustache of Australian cricketer Merv Hughes (£200,000). Lloyd's itself uses words such as "reputedly" for some of them. They are credible references, but no public documents show what those policies actually looked like.

    What about Cristiano Ronaldo's legs?

    It is the story you hear most often in Portugal. In August 2009, just after his move to Real Madrid, Goal.com reported, citing a Spanish newspaper, that the club had insured the player's legs for €100 million. We found no confirmation from the club, the player or any insurer. It is plausible, since clubs routinely insure their most valuable assets, but it remains a news report, not a confirmed fact.

    The same goes for Mariah Carey's legs, which have appeared with price tags of both $1 billion and $35 million, and for the much-quoted $27 million policy attributed to Jennifer Lopez. None of these figures has a source to back it up.

    The Loch Ness Monster was insured

    In 1971 the whisky brand Cutty Sark offered £1 million to anyone who could capture the Loch Ness Monster. To avoid the risk of having to pay out, it bought insurance, and on 29 April 1971 Lloyd's announced that it would take the risk.

    Lloyd's initially turned it down as too risky, and only changed its mind after the refusal was mocked in the press. The conditions were strict: the creature had to be more than 20 feet (about 6 metres) long and be accepted as the monster by experts at the Natural History Museum in London. Any monster caught would become the property of the underwriters. The premium was set far above the real risk, and nobody ever claimed the prize.

    This kind of contract has a name: prize indemnity insurance. A brand announces a huge, near-impossible prize, pays the insurer a known cost and is covered if someone actually wins. Pepsi did exactly this in 2003 with its "Play for a Billion" contest, which promised $1 billion to one winner. Contrary to what you often read, the risk did not sit with Lloyd's. It went to Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway.

    From the Titanic to satellites

    Not everything unusual is a stunt. In 1912 the Titanic's hull was insured for £1 million, split across several Lloyd's syndicates, for a premium of £7,500. According to Lloyd's, the claim was paid within 30 days.

    Today, one of the hardest risks to insure is in orbit. In 2023 a fault on the ViaSat-3 satellite threatened one of the largest claims in the sector's history, around $420 million. The space insurance market is so small, with 20 to 30 insurers according to Insurance Journal, that a single failed launch can weigh on a whole year's results.

    Alien abduction cover: real, but a joke

    An agency in Florida has been selling "insurance" against alien abduction since 1987 and says it has issued around 6,000 policies. The advertised payout is $10 million, paid at a rate of $1 a year. These figures come from the seller itself, and no insurer has been identified behind the certificates. In practice they are a fun keepsake, not cover that protects anyone.

    Stories that don't survive a fact-check

    Tom Jones's chest hair. In February 2008 a British tabloid reported a $6.8 million policy. Days later the singer denied the whole thing and said such a policy had never even been considered.

    The Mona Lisa. In 1962, ahead of an exhibition in the United States, the painting was valued at $100 million, a Guinness world record. But it was not insured: tight security cost less than the premium would have.

    The cheese insured by Lloyd's. An Italian bank, Credito Emiliano, has accepted Parmigiano Reggiano as collateral for loans since 1953. That part is true, and delightful, but we found no source mentioning a Lloyd's policy on the cheese.

    "Immaculate conception" insurance. It turns up on plenty of lists, without a single source to confirm it.

    Why would anyone take out a policy like this?

    Three reasons come up again and again in the genuine cases.

    The first is protecting income. A taster who loses their palate or a winemaker who loses their sense of smell can no longer do their job, and that is what the policy covers. In practice these policies work as accident, disability or loss-of-earnings cover tied to one specific ability.

    The second is publicity. A US lawyer who specialises in the subject, quoted by Fox News, describes many of these policies as mainly publicity exercises and says that, most of the time, the celebrity is not the one paying the premium. The three best-documented modern cases (Pelliccia, Ferrera and Klum) bear this out: an employer or an advertiser paid.

    The third is the way the specialist risks market works. At Lloyd's, a large or never-before-seen risk can be shared between several syndicates, each taking a slice, and the policy wording is written from scratch. When there is no data to calculate the odds, the premium is set well above the expected loss. That is why almost anything is insurable, provided someone is willing to pay the price.

    And in Portugal?

    The rule sits in Portugal's insurance contract law, approved by Decree-Law no. 72/2008 of 16 April. Article 43 states that the insured must have an interest worthy of legal protection in the risk covered, or the contract is void. In property and damage insurance, that interest concerns keeping the insured item, right or assets intact.

    In other words, the law does not ask whether the object is strange. It asks whether the person taking out the cover has something real to lose. That is also what separates insurance from a bet. The sector is supervised by the ASF (Autoridade de Supervisão de Seguros e Fundos de Pensões), Portugal's insurance and pension funds regulator. Each insurer then decides whether to accept a risk and on what terms, and there is no guarantee that an unusual risk will find someone willing to insure it.

    Lloyd's has been authorised to operate in Portugal since 1993. Since 2019, following Brexit, non-life risks from Portugal and the rest of the European Economic Area have been written by Lloyd's Insurance Company, based in Brussels, through authorised brokers and coverholders.

    The Portuguese market also has its own less obvious products, such as cover for musical instruments or for beekeeping, which protects against risks like hives being stolen. They are not quite as strange as the Loch Ness Monster, but they follow the same logic: a specific risk, a loss that can be measured and a policy designed around it.

    Got a risk that doesn't fit a standard policy?

    You probably don't need to insure your nose. But work equipment, a collection, an event or an out-of-the-ordinary activity may need terms designed around them. At Dourado's we look at your situation and set out the cover options available on the market. Request a quote: it is an enquiry, and cover only starts once a policy has been accepted and issued.

    This article is for information only and does not replace the pre-contractual information or the terms and conditions of any policy.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can you insure a part of your body?

    Yes. In practice these are accident, disability or loss-of-earnings policies linked to one specific ability, such as a voice, hands or a sense of taste. They are tailor-made contracts, usually written in the specialist risks market, and their terms, limits and exclusions depend on each policy.

    Are Cristiano Ronaldo's legs insured?

    In 2009 the press reported that Real Madrid had insured Cristiano Ronaldo's legs for €100 million. The report cited a Spanish newspaper and was never confirmed by the club, the player or any insurer.

    Does alien abduction insurance really exist?

    It exists as a novelty product, sold by an agency in Florida since 1987. According to the seller, the $10 million payout is paid at a rate of $1 a year. No insurer has been identified behind these certificates.

    Can you insure anything in Portugal?

    Portugal's insurance contract law (Decree-Law no. 72/2008) requires the insured to have an interest worthy of legal protection in the risk covered, or the contract is void. What matters is not how unusual the object is, but what the person taking out the cover stands to lose. Each insurer then decides whether to accept the risk and on what terms.

    Would you like help comparing your situation?

    Tell us what you are looking for. We review the options with you, with no obligation.

    Request a quote

    Last updated:

    A trusted network

    Our partners

    Logos of Dourado's insurance partners